Ignore the xenophobic hysteria and welcome our EU neighbours

Villagers in Clinceni, Romania cover a field with what they claim is the world's biggest ever flag

Villagers in Clinceni, Romania cover a field with what they claim is the world’s biggest ever flag

Britain is in the Orwellian middle not of a Two-Minute Hate, but a Two-Year Hate.

By Boyd Tonkin.

First published in the Independent, 27 December 2013.

This may surprise alarmed observers in Sofia and Bucharest – or even in Westminster. But one of the best-loved British books of 2013 takes the form of a fervent and heartfelt tribute to the peoples of Bulgaria and Romania. War hero, writer and traveller Patrick Leigh Fermor died in 2011 before he could publish the third volume of memoirs about his “Great Trudge” though Europe in the mid-1930s. The Broken Road, which appeared posthumously in the autumn, takes the young literary vagabond from the “Iron Gates” on the Danube across both countries to the Black Sea coast.

Everywhere he walks, Leigh Fermor relishes the landscapes and the languages. He admires the culture and the customs. Above all, he comes to love the people of the Balkan peaks and plains: always hospitable and welcoming, forever willing even in the poorest backwater to greet this penniless young Englishman with unstinting generosity, feed him, shelter him and send him on his way with blessings – and with lunch.

Now, what would happen to a late-teenage Bulgarian or Romanian, without lodging, employment or any ready cash, who started to walk, say, from Dover to Glasgow in the spring of 2014? On the evidence of British public life just now, the result would not be a glorious trek across a land of smiles, fondly remembered from a ripe old age.

The Economist magazine has already issued its number-crunched fiat in their favour. Still, this column may count as an early squeak in the almost inaudible chorus of welcome for visitors or migrants to the UK from Bulgaria and Romania. More than a few of us belong to the open-hearted country of Paddy Leigh Fermor rather than the tight little island of Godfrey Bloom. If you wish to, fellow EU citizens, I hope that you will come. Should you choose, quite legitimately, to seek work here, then I hope that you prosper for as long as you stay. And most of all, I hope against hope that our morally bankrupt political class and ruthlessly cynical media will one day start to address the underlying reasons for home-grown fears: the living-standards crisis, deep-seated job insecurity, yawning chasms in wealth and opportunity, the greed and arrogance of a pampered “super-class”, and a chronic lack of decent homes for non-millionaires. Instead, they have set out on yet another sordid scapegoat hunt. Patrick Leigh Fermor Patrick Leigh Fermor

The grievances are genuine. But the actual culprits have got clean away. A useful watchword for 2014 might run: lay the blame where it belongs. August Bebel, a wise German social democrat at the turn of the 20th century, popularised the idea that “anti-Semitism is the socialism of fools”. A century on, the quarry may have changed, but not the toxic rhetoric, nor the squalid logic of victimisation. As all the 28 million people in the so-called “A2” accession countries of the EU must understand, this lather of dread has been whipped into a perfect storm by the confluence of cannily inflammatory media and the blind funk of a shaky governing party. As a result, if you’re looking for fraudulent crystal-ball predictions, outrageously deceitful hucksterism and a brisk trade in ideological scrap and junk, there’s no need to visit some mythical gypsy encampment. You can find all that and more via any visit to Westminster, TV studios and newsrooms – plus a detour, of course, to the Ukip HQ.

Crashing rollers of anti-immigrant vitriol break day after day, loud as an end-of-year storm surge, and just as implacable. Anyone who resists this tide – who says without any niggling proviso that all legal incomers from European Union member states, as from -everywhere else, presumptively deserve trust, goodwill, courtesy and fair dealing – may feel just now like the enemy within. The tone of paranoia, suspicion and targeted hatred has made British political discourse through

2013 resemble propaganda-fuelled dictatorships such as – well, let’s start with Nicolae Ceausescu’s Romania and Todor Zhivkov’s Bulgaria. As regards the citizens of those states, Britain is in the Orwellian middle not of a Two-Minute Hate, but a Two-Year Hate.

Plenty of the worried who fear this as-yet-phantom army of immigrants will have spent Christmas paying lip service at least to the festival’s religious roots. Presumably – and this, I’m afraid, is a rhetorical device shamelessly nicked from the works of Charles Dickens – their edition of the Bible fails to include the exhortation from Deuteronomy that insists “Love ye therefore the stranger, for ye were strangers in the land of Egypt”, the lines from Matthew’s gospel that run “For I was hungry, and ye gave me meat: I was thirsty, and ye gave me drink: I was a stranger, and ye took me in”, still less the advice of the Letter to the Hebrews: “Be not forgetful to entertain strangers, for thereby some have entertained angels unawares”. A few weeks ago, Nigel Farage commented: “We need a much more muscular defence of our Judaeo-Christian heritage.” To which one might reply: precisely.

Sentimental? Impractical? Airy-fairy? No more so that than the speculative pseudo-statistics that bedevil this “debate”. As to the likely numbers involved, absolute confusion reigns. An even-handed House of Commons briefing paper recently noted that the Foreign Office’s own inquiry into probable figures (commissioned from the National Institute of Economic and Social Research) had concluded that “it is not possible to predict the scale of future migration from Bulgaria and Romania to the UK numerically”. The Commons paper, by the way, also shows why the often-quoted Migration Watch prediction of circa 50,000 net arrivals per annum from Bulgaria and Romania is skewed. The numbers rest on an untested forward projection from events after the 2004 EU entry of Poland and its neighbours (the so-called “A8” countries) on to a wholly different set of circumstances.

Among the factors that suggest “low levels of migration”, the Commons researchers cite the obvious fact that “all remaining transitional controls will expire in all EU countries at the same time”. Among factors that may pull the numbers upwards are “high unemployment rates … in those EU countries that have so far been the preferred destinations for A2 nationals”, mainly Italy and Spain. In short, we don’t yet know. Maybe the invading wave will be crested by some of the estimated 14,000 doctors and 50,000 nurses who have left Romania since it joined the EU in 2007. If so, then our steam-driven pundits should on principle refuse treatment when their apoplectic xenophobia lands them in A&E.

Even if the feared influx of low-skill job-seekers does occur, and does put pressure on underfunded services in certain areas, then public figures still have a choice to make. Some of the windier press invective that craven politicians have done nothing to deflate – especially against Roma people – pretty much amounts to incitement to racial violence.

Whoever wins the dismal numbers game in 2014, a failure to condemn that sort of hate speech opens the door to further barbarism in political life.

We have been here, many times, before. Back in 1517, Londoners rioted on “Evil May Day” against foreign workers. According to legend, the mob was calmed by the then under-sheriff of London, Sir Thomas More. About 75 years later, the event was dramatised in a multi-authored play about the life of More – the kind of stage “biopic” common in the Elizabethan theatre. In the second act, when he faces down the racist rioters of London, the play’s language suddenly leaps into life. More’s great speech makes the case against anti-immigrant agitation with a moral force that still sings out today.

“Grant them removed,” says More about the detested foreigners. “Imagine that you see the wretched strangers,/ Their babies at their backs and their poor luggage,/ Plodding to the ports and costs for transportation.” “What had you got?” he asks the mob. “I’ll tell you. You had taught/ How insolence and strong hand should prevail.” In other words, mob rule – of the kind that, these days, tries to smash international treaties and tear up EU agreements. And what if the lawless migrant-bashers had to move abroad themselves, “to anywhere that not adheres to England”? In exile, “Would you be pleased/ To find a nation of such barbarous temper,/ That, breaking out in hideous violence,/ Would not afford you an abode on earth?” Just put yourselves in the foreigner’s shoes, More counsels: “What would you think/ To be thus used? This is the strangers’ case;/ And this your mountainish inhumanity.”

There used to be almost as much heated argument around the authorship of this passage (in a script known as “Hand D”) as about the imminent levels of migration from “A2” states. Now, a kind of scholarly consensus prevails. That scene was most probably written by William Shakespeare. Across the political mountains of inhumanity, let’s hope that the latest torrent, or quite possibly, trickle of “strangers” can locate and enjoy Shakespeare’s country.

Culture aside, a well-sourced report released this week by the Centre for Economic and Business Research argues that Britain will over the coming years overtake Germany as the strongest economy in Europe. And which ace do we hold up our sleeve as the Old Continent grows even older, less productive and more state-dependent? Why, “positive demographics with continuing immigration”. On which note, we should wish even the frostiest of Europhobes Chestita Nova Godina and Un An Nou Fericit!


8 thoughts on “Ignore the xenophobic hysteria and welcome our EU neighbours

  1. Christos Paganakis

    The Florentine Historian Petruccio Ubaldino , who wrote about the campaign to defeat the Spanish Armada in 1588 , as an eye witness , says ; –
    ” It is easier to find flocks of White Crows , than one Englishman who loves a Foreigner , either as a master , or as a companion in his own house , even if he comes as a benefactor ”

    Well ,nothing much has changed there in four-and-a-quarter centuries , has it ?

    He goes on to describe the propaganda rumours put about among the English people as to what the Spaniards might do to them , and says ” These things being easily believed , the whole of the lowest and most credulous part of the people were moved to a mortal and dangerous hatred of all foreigners living here ” and ” that these ( rumours ) and other things of the same ,greatly irritated the people ”

    Again , exactly as is the case now .

    The English are an insular people – The Poet George Seferis commented that ” They are lonely ; like islands ” , and probably only the Japanese have a similar sense of ” Otherness ” and consequent Antixenia .
    ( Xenophobia is a miscategorisation – we dont FEAR foreigners , we just ( at best ) are a little ” sniffy ” about them , or (at worst ) loathe and despise them for not being ” Us ” )
    Unfortunately the English are also ( in the mass ) the worst educated in Western Europe , and kept the worst informed by a media machine almost wholly in the hands of the Elite .

    Since the 1980s , the real Unemployment figure in England ( not the contrived official statistic ; – I mean the number of people who would take a reasonable job for a reasonable payrate if that was available locally ) has varied from circa 2 million to 4 million ;
    But the Elite only read up to page 2 of the Ladybird book of Economics , where it says increasing the Labour supply reduces wages costs , and increases fear of losing your job , therefore creating Worker biddability , and so have been complicit in failing to stem Immigration from all around the world , not just from the E U .

    But the Elite then play another foul trick , and propagandise the people into hatred of these new arrivals , the system’s latest docile serfs for minimum wages .

    As humans we carry hardwired redundant survival behaviours evolved over 2,000,000 years of being chased about as Ape-descended Hunter-Gatherer extended family clan groups , in the African Grasslands . Competition in that environment neccesitated protecting the ” Us ” group against the ” Them ” groups , and it is particularly telling that much of this present vicious propaganda campaign focuses on ” Them ” coming here to our territory and taking OUR resources .
    Perfectly targeted to press the default ” Hostile Competitors Sighted ” alarm button in our heads , there are some very clever psychologists at work behind all this .

    Dont believe me ? Visit any English football league match and watch the opposing fans contingents in action , and then try to say we have all evolved .

    Three last thoughts , then I’ll shut up .
    1 ) – Five years ago , there was a knock on the door , a young man and woman , both bedraggled , who handed me a note ( on that odd eastern european writing paper that has a grid on it and is too blue ) which said they were selling sketches to fund a tour of the UK , and please to look at them ?
    So I brought them in , gave them coffee , established they were students from Krakow , Poles , and duly paid too much for a very nice print , of a charcoal sketch of a Hare – a very pretty thing , and hanging in my kitchen now .
    Two days later our local evening paper carried the warning that two suspicious people ” of eastern european appearance ( now what the hell is THAT ) had been noted selling paintings door to door , and that anyone seeing them should call the Police .
    2 ) – Two years ago , another knock , and this time it’s a lone young woman , again bedraggled , foreign accent , trying to sign up people to charity donations by direct debit .
    Well I am poor , and mean and hard-hearted , so I wouldn’t sign for that , but brought her in to dry out and gave her coffee , and established she was French .
    She told me she thought most people here were all right , but one of my neighbours ( she wouldn’t say which ) had told her to ” F**k off back to Latvia ! ” and slammed the door in her face .
    3 ) – I had a minor eye test at the local hospital today . The receptionist was a black lady with a rich Jamaican accent ; The nurse who did my initial test was from Portugal . The lady operating the eye examination camera thingy was from Bulgaria , and the Consultant who saw me was a lady from Uzbekhistan , with better English than mine .

    This present propaganda campaign in the UK demonising the people of Romania and Bulgaria is SHAMEFUL , awful , racist . Dr Goebbels would be proud of it .

    1. proverbs6to10 Post author

      I disagree with one point near the start. I think the English do like foreigners (unless of course they are French!! 🙂 ) as long as “the foreigner” shares British values – and if they do they are welcomed with open arms. I certainly know many Romanians who will make model British citizens.

      1. Weltbuehne

        Yes, Tom, but they have to be allowed to demonstrate their willingness to integrate, and that is difficult when the locals are exhibiting lynch mob behaviour.

        Resisting that is not the same thing as saying everyone can come and they’re all great guys. The world is a bit more complicated than that, and it’s the great simplifiers who are dangerous.

        I am of the generation who ask people who argue from a national/racial, us/them perspective to at least also consider the class/economic perspective as well. Deregulation, privatization, public spending and tax cuts (neoliberalism) are at least as significant as immigration.

        Let’s talk about it without what the Germans call totschlag arguments. The word means literally manslaughter, here it means arguments which brook no reply, such as ‘this island is full’, instead of ‘this island cannot support more than its current population’, which allows the possibility of a reasoned reply.

  2. Martin Pusey Nichols

    I have appreciated reading this well written article but I do not wholly share those sentiments it expresses. After all who in the real world turns the other cheek ? Perhaps one should, but it just does not happen ! I live in France, not England, and there is outrage here at how the Roms occupy land that is not theirs, turn it into dirty slum caravan site; they then turn to housebreaking and pickpocketing in nearby tourist haunts to support their lifestyle, when they do not attempt to earn an honest living at the traffic lights attempting with a filthy squeezee to clean your already clean windscreen – and shouting obscenities at you when you drive off without so much as thanking them ! No, sir, I am so sorry not to be that impeccable Christian that Boyd Tonkin expects of us.

  3. Alun

    On the question of immigration – as someone who was brought up in Africa, and has travelled widely, I have not a jot of bias in terms of colour or creed – but I firmly believe that this small island is full up – just try driving up the M4 – M5 – M6 and see for yourself. Having said that of course we should take in real refugees as from Syria. Blwyddyn Newydd Dda

  4. Weltbuehne

    Well, thank God for that!

    As a happily emigrated expat, my jaw has been dropping painfully day after day as I read the comments on a staggering number of articles in the Guardian about this immigration hysteria.

    I am not the straw man ‘Guardian reader’ saying ‘come all ye’, and if I lived in Britain I would insist that the authorities try to predict what is going to happen, and make appropriate provision, but most of the torrent of comments are not even barely concealed racism: they are overt racism, more revealed than concealed by the fatuous justifications.

    So thank you again, there are some people in Britain still defending common humanity against mob rule. I was beginning to wonder.

    Germany is facing the same situation humourlessly and boringly, God bless ’em.

  5. antoon van coillie

    Indeed, where is the spirit of 1914, when Britain took in 250.000 Belgian refugees in 6 weeks ! Britain gave them shelter, welcome & most of all Hope !


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.